Oversite

A Personal View

logo









Oversite Home Page













Specialness

By Bruce Barbour - October 2026 (Version 1.1)

Aristotle

Aristotle proposed that human purpose is to achieve eudamonia, which translates as flourishing or fulfillment, and also includes happiness.

The reasoning behind this is fourfold:
  1. Aristotle states that every action by a human is aimed at achieving a goal or a "good". However nearly all of these goals are not ends in themselves. For example a person may desire a lot of money and seek that as a goal. However the desire for money is not for the money itself but for what can be bought with the money:- the car, the house, the holiday. But even here the person doesn't desire the car for the car itself but for what the car provides: transport, prestige etc. This sort of inquiry can go on over a number of iterations but in the end the person will get to the realization that what is finally desired is happiness. Every goal prior to this is just a step along the way to achieving happiness. And there is nothing beyond happiness that a person desires. (The answer to the question "Why do you want to be happy?" is "Because I do." It is not to achieve some other end.) Happiness - or as Aristotle called it eudaimonia or flourishing - is the "good" people desire for its own sake.
  2. Aristotle claims that everything has a purpose (telos) and how well the object serves that purpose determines whether the object is good or bad. The example provided is that of a knife. The special attribute that makes a knife a knife is its ability to cut things. This is its reason for existence. Most other objects do not have this attribute - for example a chair cannot cut things - it wasn't designed to do so and if it did then it would be a very bad chair. If the knife is a vegetable knife then it is a good knife if it cuts vegetables well - efficiently and cleanly. It is a bad knife if it doesn't. By cutting well it is fulfilling its purpose.
  3. If the purpose of the knife is to carryout its special attribute and to cut well then what is the purpose of humanity? Extrapolating from the knife example Aristotle reasoned that the purpose of a human was to use a human's special attribute well. According to Aristotle the special attribute that humans have that set them apart from other things on Earth was a humans' ability for rationality and reason. It is an attribute that nothing else on Earth can do, at least not as well as humans. While higher level animals, say dolphins and dogs, show an ability to reason it is not at the level of humans.
  4. Aristotle's next step was to claim that by using rationality and reason a person will conclude that the way to achieve eudamonia/happiness is through determining and then exercising the virtues. Through exercising the virtues the person is being a "good" person because they are living life in accordance with their purpose and would therefore achieve eudaimonia.
It is interesting to note that Aristotle's claimed purpose does not reference a god or to anything "supernatural". Aristotle defines a purpose for humanity only referring to what he sees as intrinsic to the nature of human beings. Aristotle specifically nominated reason as the special attribute of humans that defines a purpose for humanity. However it should be noted that Aristotle's use of purpose describes a functional purpose and not necessarily a "higher" or a metaphysical purpose.

Is Happiness the Purpose of Humanity?

There is an issue with Aristotle's claim that happiness is the purpose of a human. A person can use their reason, discover and then exercise the virtues but still not be happy. Their circumstances might not be conducive to happiness. They could be in a dreadful drought or there might be a plague ripping through their community or one of many other reasons.(1) Does this mean that the person has not achieved their purpose - solely due to their circumstances? In better circumstances the same person would achieve happiness - and therefore achieve their purpose? This seems problematic.

I suggest that happiness is not the purpose of a human. However I do agree with the Aristotelian logic that happiness is the good that we desire for its own sake. But I also believe that what we desire is of little importance to an objective purpose for humanity. Many philosophers believe that desire causes suffering rather than happiness.

So what is human purpose? Let's look at the example of an knife. Aristotle said the purpose of the knife was to cut well. Once it has done this it has achieved its purpose. Getting a bowl of well cut vegetables is just a good outcome from the use of a knife that has fulfilled its purpose. I suggest that human happiness is the same as a bowl of well cut vegetables is to the knife - a desirable outcome but not the purpose itself.

Sticking within Aristotle's framework and expanding the knife analogy this would suggest that human purpose is doing the thing that humans do better than anything else on Earth. According to Aristotle this is to reason well. This suggests that (at least part of) a human's purpose is to reason well.

Aristotle suggests that if a human reasons well they will recognise that developing and exercising the virtues is the way to become a person of good character. And by being of good character a person will be a good person. One of the consequences of this is to achieve happiness. However any happiness achieved by this path is a by-product of reasoning well. I recognise this as a possible route to happiness but not the only one.

A question that needs to be considered is how does "reasoning" and "exercising the virtues" make a human happy? These are two separate functions both of which have happiness potential. Firstly in accordance with Aristotle's suggestion, by exercising the virtues the person is becoming and then being a "good" person. In this case good means functionally good, like a sharp knife that cuts well is a good knife. Though in the case of a person functional goodness would also include moral goodness. By being and acting good functionally the person gains a sense of competence and a sense of satisfaction. By achieving competence and exercising that competence the person feels a sense of happiness and even eudaimonia.

Secondly if happiness is gained from achieving and exercising competence it can be competence in aspects other than virtue (as well as virtue). Consequently I claim that happiness can be achieved from achieving competence in a human's special attribute of reason and then exercising that reason well - that is: competently. As an example if a scientist firstly developed their learning and reasoning through study and research and then used their reasoning to, say, come up with a cure for a disease then this would be a source of happiness for them. Or a judge may achieve some happiness through competently exercising reason and determining a particularly legally difficult and important case. Neither of these cases are directly related to virtue, though it can be argued that they are virtuous if done for non-selfish reasons, but they do have happiness creation potential.

Specialness

Definition

When something is defined as special it means it is distinguished by some unusual quality, it is in some way superior, or it is designed for a particular purpose or occasion. It is often used to describe something that is unique or held in particular esteem(2).

Special Attributes

A human attribute can be described as special because no other species on Earth has the attribute, at least not to the level of the human. The human attribute is at the pinnacle of complexity and functionality of life on Earth. Consequently they are unique on earth and in the universe Or if not unique in the Universe then very rare.

Aristotle identifies only one special attribute, rationality and reason, that differentiates humans from everything else on Earth. But there are other attributes that, like rationality and reason, are not found elsewhere on Earth, in any other life form. These may also be important and could be considered as part of a system of ethics.

I propose that instead of just the one special attribute of reason, humans have a number of additional attributes that are also special. That is, they are either not found in other entities, or their existence in humanity is at a higher level than in other entities. There is no reason why something must only have one special attribute - think Swiss army knife. My suggested list of special attributes for humans and in some cases life in general is provided below(3):
  1. a. Complexity. Humans are very complex organisms. As far as we know the human brain is the most complex structure in the universe.(4) 
    b. Complexity in a Universe of Increasing Entropy: - Our complexity has occurred in a Universe that is firstly governed by a number of physical laws that work in accordance with observed cause and effect. Secondly the Universe is subject to increasing entropy in which objects and systems exist in an environment where entropy increases. Higher energy objects and systems tend to lose energy over time to lower energy objects and environments. All life, including human life, seems to go against this trend.  Over billions of years since life first formed in the primordial swamps, life has developed increasing complexity(5). 
  2. Consciousness. Humans have developed consciousness. This gives us the ability to recognise that we are alive. Consciousness also allows us to look out into the universe in awe and wonder and try to understand the Universe and our place in it. As far as we know nothing else in the universe can do that.
  3. Free Will. as a sub working hypothesis I believe that humans have free will - the self exists and can make autonomous choices. If this is true this contravenes the cause and effect observation and would undoubtedly be special.
  4. Intellectual and Physical Skills. Humans have a level of intelligence. In combination with this we can have high level physical skills which needs intelligence, knowledge and manual dexterity. (Aristotle seems to discount the specialness of physical skills.) There may not be intelligence elsewhere in the universe. No other animal on Earth has the manual dexterity skills that we have. An aspect of our intelligence is our ability to be rational and to reason (recognised by Aristotle as the sole special attribute). We can choose between alternatives and to an extent decide the direction of our life, though limitations exist due to our circumstances and other people. We can foresee a future (even if that foresight may be not correct) and can plan for and even change it, if possible. We have imagination, imagining things and situations that may or may not occur. Do any other animals on Earth do any of this? Do higher level animals imagine or plan? If they do then certainly not as well as humans.
  5. Creativity. Humans are hugely creative, creating things that are new to the Universe in the fields of science, engineering, arts and literature. Humans create beauty in the arts. Cause and effect creates by obedience to sophisticated but dumb rules of nature. And in some cases beauty is created - witness the beauty of a flower. The fact that this occurs is another factor that makes the Universe overall special - there is no reason that beauty has to occur out of cause and effect. Usually cause and effect by itself creates disorder.
    Human creativity seems to go at least a step or two beyond the beauty created by the rules of simple cause and effect. The beauty of the music of Mozart has no parallel in nature. Humans create both beauty and artifacts by using intelligence and consciousness, to mold the natural laws to our will.
  6. Fine Tuning. The "fine tuning" of the universe. There are a number of "universal constants" in the "laws of nature" that if they had of been slightly different the Universe would not have formed. The gravity constant is the one most often quoted but there are a series of other constants as well that all had to be very close to the values we observe in our Universe or else the Universe would not have formed and developed over billions of years. And, of course, we would not exist.

    On top of this there is the form of the natural laws themselves. If they had of been different the Universe would not have formed or would have been very different.
* * * * * *
This list of special attributes is not final or conclusive. Some people may consider other attributes of humanity and life to also be special. They could be included in the general list or in their own list of special attributes if they considered it warranted. Some people might drop one or two of those listed for a variety of reasons. I will write more on this later.

Are the attributes included in this list actually special? Consider one of the attributes - Creativity. Who, after listening to a piece of Mozart's music, is willing to say that that music is not special? I suggest no-one, or very few. If not Mozart's music then consider your favourite music. Isn't their music special? Consider human created literature - also special. Within the special attribute of Intellectual and Physical Skills consider human created science and discovery. Consider the superb skills and artistry of a concert pianist. All special. The evidence of special attributes in humans is at everyone's fingertips on YouTube, on television and in the books in the home and at the local library. It is available in interactions between people. It is evident in the parts and operations of your own body.

With some additional reflection most people will agree that all of the attributes in the list are special. I will go further and say that this specialness is a fact. It is (capital K) Knowledge. Each special attribute is unique to humanity, at least to the level that we have the special attribute. They are unique in our part of the Universe. Even if intelligent alien life is discovered it does not diminish the specialness. It just means that it is more widespread.

Uniqueness is sufficient for the items to be considered special. And usually with special items, items that are rare if not unique, we want to preserve, and to enhance the specialness if there is potential for enhancement.

Aristotle suggested that humans could achieve happiness - the one good desired for its own sake - by the use of the one special attribute nominated by him, that is reason and using that reason to determine that to live a virtuous life is happiness inducing. However I have suggested that humans have more than the one special attribute - I have nominated six. By extending Aristotle's reasoning, a human's purpose may not just be to reason well and to develop and exercise the virtues, but to develop, gain competence in, and exercise these other special attributes as well. At least for those special attributes that are amenable to being developed and exercised.

Four of the six nominated special attributes are amenable to enhancement by humans. These are consciousness, intellectual and physical skills, creativity and free will, though note that "intellectual and physical skills" is a collection of a number of separate but related special attributes, which includes the ability to reason. The other attributes in the list are also special however they are more related to the specialness of the Universe and the Earth which allowed humanity and life to evolve.

It is apparent that not everyone is going to be able to develop all of the nominated special attributes, except for a few exceptional people sometimes called polymaths. However any person should be able to work on developing one or a number of the special attributes in themselves. People, individually and as humanity, should live life so as to continue and enhance the special attributes and also continue to exercise the competencies gained in the special attributes. In doing so a person becomes a "good" human, flourishes, and also achieve, as a by-product, a sense of satisfaction and happiness.

How are these special attributes developed so they can be exercised with competence? As preliminary suggestions:
  • consciousness might be enhanced by mindful awareness and meditation(6), and immersion in beauty, both human-made and natural;
  • intellectual and physical skills might be enhanced by education, training and practice in one or a number of fields, and also by improving reasoning ability and also gaining mastery in one or a number of fields of physical and/or mental activity;
  • creativity might be enhanced by learning and participating in one or a number of the forms of arts;
  • free will might be enhanced by working on improving personal autonomy, making consciously reasoned decisions rather than performing actions in a reactionary way - by not succumbing to simple cause and effect.
In all cases it is not sufficient to just develop, to have and to feel competent with these attributes. They must be exercised, that is used. As Aristotle suggested with both reason and virtue.

Is Enhancing Our Special Attributes Our Purpose?

As much as Aristotle made the leap to say that the very purpose of humanity is to achieve Eudaimonia I can not. Nor can I say that our purpose is to use and to enhance our reasoning. Or that that has metaphysical significance. Similarly for the other special attributes. I cannot say that these associations have met the required level of reasoned proof to be classed as Knowledge.

However that said it is clear that humans do treat something that is classed as special as worthy of being protected and preserved. And to also be enhanced if that is possible. For example historical sites are usually protected and preserved because of their uniqueness. They are special. Great care will be taken to protect and preserve examples of artwork that are deemed special due to their uniqueness. When we find a place of great natural beauty or great uniqueness, efforts are made to protect it by declaring the area as a National Park or some other protected classification to prevent destruction. We endeavour to preserve and protect species that may be approaching extinction (often due to human actions - but that's another issue).

Humans often think and act in a way that is aimed at preserving and protecting specialness. I propose that humans should also act in this way for the special attributes in themselves and in others.

One of the main differences between humans and the other special things that are protected and preserved by humans is that there are a large number of humans that have the special attributes. Does that large number diminish the specialness within humans? I have to say no. We all still have the special attributes - consciousness, intellectual and physical skills, creativity and free will. These are special regardless of number. The creative attribute in a person is still special even if there is 100 of them, or 10,000. Consciousness is still special regardless of number.

Most ethical systems have rules against murder. As such humans are recognised as special by the general populous even if the reason why this is so is not consciously acknowledged. I propose that part of the reason for this is the special attributes that humans possess. Most people do not think that just because there are 8 billion plus humans it is therefore OK to knock off a few here and there. Although some people act as though that is acceptable to achieve a goal it would not align with most ethical systems(7) And if it does align to their ethical system that ethical system should be viewed as suspect.(8)

Kant

One of the criticisms of Aristotle's Virtue Ethics is that it can seem very self centred. It is about the person themself becoming a good person but it doesn't explicitly express concern about whether other people also become good people.(9) While other people and society in general would benefit greatly from a single person obtaining good character and exercising the virtues, society would benefit immensely more if many other people also developed good character.

Over 2 millennia after Aristotle, Immanuel Kant wrote in "The Doctrine of Virtue":

"There are two sorts of ends that it is our duty to have: our own perfection and the happiness of others.

"Perfection" includes both our natural perfection (the development of our talents, skills, and capacities of understanding) and moral perfection (our virtuous disposition).

A person's "happiness" is the greatest rational whole of the ends the person set for the sake of her own satisfaction."

From “The Doctrine of Virtue, Part II of The Metaphysics of Morals”
by Immanuel Kant (quote taken from Wikipedia).
Bolding and paragraph breaks added.

Here Kant is proposing that humans have two duties:
  • Our own perfection - both "natural" perfection and moral perfection; and
  • The happiness of others.
Aristotle's Virtue Ethics partially aligns with the first dot point. Aristotle didn't write about "our own perfection" but was interested in the person developing "the virtues" and a "good character", which aligns well with moral perfection. A person of good character exercising the virtues is going to behave in an ethical manner. Kant's natural perfection includes the development of talents, skills, and capacities of understanding. "Capacities of understanding" is aligned to Aristotle's development of reasoning capacity.

Kant's inclusion of the "happiness of others" as moral duty extends past what Aristotle suggested and arises from Kant's requirement to treat "humans as an end in themselves and not just as a means". Kant does not say we have a duty to assure the perfection of other people - that could require us to impose our will on them and would impinge on their autonomy. However by the same token if we are convinced that their self improvement, if not perfection, would put them on a reliable path towards a happy life then this would seem to suggest we can or perhaps should provide the opportunity to other people for training and guidance towards the path of "perfection", if this is feasible. As well as doing other things to provide people with the opportunity for happiness.

All of Kant's "perfections" lie within the suggested special attribute of "intellectual and physical skills". The special attributes list does not mention "moral perfection" but if Aristotle's reasoning is accepted this will arise naturally out of a person's enhanced reasoning which will lead to the development of virtues.

Ethics and the Special Attributes

Purpose and Ethics

Alasdair McIntyre in his 1951 book "After Virtue" argued that the main problem of Western ethics was that: (1) there was the lack of agreement on what human purpose (or teleology) is, and (2) this lack of agreement on purpose destroyed the foundations on which ethics was previously (pre-Enlightenment) based.

All the ethical systems proposed post Enlightenment fundamentally conflicted with each other in that they did not have a common basis. McIntyre thought that some aspects of the words and language of the previous ethical system remained (such as "justice" and "rights") however agreement on what the words and language actual meant and which took precedence had been destroyed, even though this was often not acknowledged under the new ethical systems. He argued that as there was no common basis and not even a common language of ethics this made agreement on ethical questions at least very difficult and in some cases impossible. All ethical arguments ultimately became arguments based on emotion (emotivism) - what the person felt about the ethical issue. And people had different emotional responses to the various situations.

McIntyre argued that in order for humanity to be able to agree on ethical issues, or if not agree at least to be able to sensibly discuss ethical issues, people need to come to agreement on what the Enlightenment thinkers had discarded, a consensus on human purpose.

McIntyre proposed the rebuilding of a modern form of teleology (purpose) and a return to a form of virtue ethics, though not necessarily the same virtues that Aristotle had listed. He proposed that the modern virtues would be developed or discovered through communities of shared practices. These communities could be based around shared practices of farming, medicine, engineering, chess and many other possibilities. A bit like professional associations and trade guilds. These communities would aim at developing excellence in the various practices associated with their expertise, and in the process the members of the community would gain various virtues such as patience, honesty and humility. These virtues would be practiced within the communities but would also spread out and be practiced throughout society.

I agree with McIntyre's assessment that modern ethical systems lack a common basis making agreement on ethical issues difficult. However there are a number of aspects that I don't agree with.

McIntyre thought that the basis for ethics had to be agreement on human purpose, as proposed in Aristotelian ethics. However the purpose proposed in Aristotelian ethics - and consequently McIntyre's proposal - is a functional purpose rather than an ultimate or metaphysical purpose. Functional purpose is not a strong enough basis for ethics. While ultimate purpose would be a good (in fact the best) basis for ethics, as the Existentialist have pointed out, the Universe refuses to reveal to humanity whether we have an ultimate purpose or a meaning(10).

The second issue is that the process of determining or re-imagining human purpose proposed by McIntyre has been unsuccessful. It has been 75 years since the publication of "After Virtue" and progress toward a common basis of ethics has not occurred. It would require a major re-ordering of society to become remotely possible. I cannot see this occurring at any time in the near future. 

As a result of this if we are going to hope to get an agreed basis for ethics we should look for another basis other than functional purpose and virtues, however derived. If subsequently human purpose is agreed on this may reinforce the non-purpose based basis of ethics, provided they are compatible.

Proposed Basis for Ethics

If we could have agreement on metaphysical purpose that would be good as a basis for ethics. Though as discussed it is problematic so we need to look elsewhere. The question is what would be needed as a non purpose based basis for ethics. It would have to be something that the vast majority of people could agree on and see as important and perhaps even significant. Something that is applicable to all humans. And something that doesn't radically contradict most of the many and varied current beliefs and views on purpose and meaning.

I propose that ethics should be based around the recognition of the human special attributes. The ethical significance attributed to humanity is related to the special attributes that humans process and the cosmic rarity of those special attributes. It is related to a property or properties of humanity rather than a functional purpose such as Aristotle suggested. These properties already are or can be recognised by most people as special and worth preserving and enhancing. The specialness of the attributes can be regarded as Knowledge.

It is an ethical basis that does not rely on a person's emotional response to a situation. Resolution of ethical questions will involve reason. The recognition of the specialness of the special attributes can be a firm basis for ethics that can have wide acceptance.

The recognition of the special attributes has two impacts. It impacts firstly on how we live and treat ourselves as people with special attributes. However the recognition needs to go beyond our own personal special attributes to the special attributes of other humans. Of the wider population. It should impact on how we treat and interact with other members of the human species. Consideration of the special attributes of other people provides a common basis for determining our ethical duties to others.

Our duty to ourselves(11) is to recognise and not to purposely degrade our special attributes. While I am not prepared to go as far as Kant and label it is an imperative duty it is a good idea (a should rather than a must) to aim towards our own perfection by the enhancement of some or all our special attributes if only for the selfish reason that, provided we exercise those attributes, it is a route to happiness. Our perfection is not possible so it is an ideal, like Nietzsche's view of the perfected man, the Ubermensche.(12) But enhancement of our special attributes is possible and can be an ongoing project. Note that while it is a self improvement ethic it is only aimed at self improvement in the special attributes. It does not aim at obtaining greater power or status or increasing efficiency or wealth, among other possible "improvement" scenarios. These may be by-products but are not of ethical significance and should not be sought for themselves.

Our ethical duty to others is to recognise and to take into consideration the other person's special attributes. If it can be avoided to not degrade another person's special attributes. We have a duty not to interfere with or stand in the way of the other person exercising and enhancing their special attributes. There are exceptions and limitations to this. For example if the person's exercise of a special attribute impinges on what other people are doing or wish to do. (Improving your creativity special attribute by practicing the trumpet at 3 am is not on! Practicing other times may also be problematic in certain areas. There would be lots of other situations where limitations would apply.)

Finally there is an ethical duty to consider the provision of opportunities for the enhancement of other people's special attributes. Again provision is not an imperative but something that should be taken into consideration especially in relation to a society's provision of facilities and services, both at a government and a voluntary organisation level and through our individual actions. It is a good idea that it be considered when proposing works and services. However it is up to the individual as to whether they avail themselves of any opportunity provided to enhance their special attributes.

Accommodation of Existing Belief Systems

One of the benefits of this proposed basis of ethics is that it can accommodate and work along side of many belief systems provided that the legitimacy of most of the special attributes I have listed can be accommodated within the belief system.

As stated earlier the list of special attributes is not final or exclusive. Some people may consider other attributes of humans to also be special. They could be included in the general list or in their own list of special attributes if they considered it warranted. Some people for various reasons may think that one or more of the listed special attributes should not apply or are not special. These can be dropped. That is their decision. Provided that it is only one or two that are dropped it can be accommodated within the overarching view that human's have special attributes. It should also be noted that under different belief systems the reason that a special attribute is considered special may also differ for various reasons. As a basis for ethics this is acceptable. The flexibility may allow the concept of the importance of the special attributes to sit along side of their beliefs and other philosophical views.

It may also be accommodated within a future, yet to be determined, belief system.

Humanism

The special attributes should be compatible with humanist philosophy. It could be adopted fully by many humanists without many issues, though there maybe some, as people have a variety of views and beliefs. However it is not exclusively a humanist philosophy as that might dissuade others from accepting it. You do not have to be a humanist to acknowledge the special attributes. As will be discussed below it can be incorporated as part of other belief systems just as well.

Religion in General

Arguably most religions either aim at producing a better human or have that as a secondary effect. Religious people, as a result of their beliefs and the teachings of their religion, may act virtuously and morally and may refrain from various activities that could be thought of as harmful to themselves and others due to the teaching of their religion. Some people of course do not - but they are generally not considered to be good practitioners. And some interpretations of religion, often by cult leaders or some religious sects, do not encourage activity that would be considered ethical and in some cases allow and even encourage clearly unethical actions. However most mainline religions do encourage the bulk of their adherents to follow an ethical way of life.

The acceptance that humans have special attributes is not mutually exclusive with the beliefs contained in the religion. The religion may either be able to incorporate an acceptance of the special attributes or at least would not reject it. The reason an attribute is considered special may change but the specialness remains.

Christianity

Belief in a Christian God does not invalidate all of the special attributes that I have listed though some may run afoul in some Christian denominations. For example some Christian denominations would reject outright evolution (inferred in Special Attribute 1b) - instead believing in creation over seven days - while others may allow it saying evolution is all part of God's plan. Similarly with the other special attributes they may say that the special attributes are still special but the reason they exist and that they are special is solely due to God, part of His creation and plan. And they may want to add other special attributes such as being "children of God" and "part of God's plan".

Existentialism

I would like to boldly suggest that it can even be accepted by some existentialists, though existentialism is such a broad church that this is perhaps not that surprising. After all Kierkegaard is included among their ranks. All they need is to believe in the special attributes. Which is not difficult with a bit of consideration.

Atheism

I also boldly suggest that it can even be accepted by some atheists. Atheism like existentialism is a broad church. Atheists don't believe in a god, but it does not mean they cannot believe in the special attributes of humanity. I have argued that this should be apparent through reasoned thought. Sufficient to be accepted as Knowledge. Though the reason why they think they are special may vary.

Some beliefs are not going to accommodate specialness. For example nihilism and anti-natalism. 100% agreement is never possible on anything.

Summary Ethics

I suggest that many different religions and belief systems may be able to accept the special attributes of humanity and to use this as a basis for or a supplement to their ethical systems. It provides the possibility of a common basis for ethics.

Is this a panacea for resolving all ethical dilemmas? No. But then nothing is, so long as people can disagree about interpretation and implementation. But I suggest that it is a better basis for ethics than the current situation, which has no consistent basis.

* * * * * * * * * * * *
Notes:

(1) Though in these circumstances I would suggest that the person still exercising the virtues would be happier than if they weren't.

(2) Based on the Miriam Webster Dictionary online definition.

(3) I have said the nominated attributes of humans are special rather than unique because life could (probably does!) exist in other parts of the Universe. That alien life may also have special attributes. However I do contend that humans are unique in our little corner of the Universe. It is certainly special in our local area of the Galaxy, which is a pretty big area.

(4) If there is other life in the Universe with complex brains then that might be challenged. However if life is found elsewhere (probably when rather than if)  I hope we - and they - mutually recognise each other's special attributes and that we are part of the same specialness. If it is found that there is no other life or no other life with consciousness this would emphasize the specialness of humanity's special attributes.

(5) Though scientists may argue this gain for humanity is at the expense of greater loses elsewhere in the system..

(6) There are reports that some people can have a bad experience with meditation. In which case stop and if issues continue they should seek professional advice.

(7) The ethics of war - if this is not an oxymoron - is a special case.

(8) This is why simplistic Utilitarianism is suspect. See my critique and suggested modifications of utilitarianism.

(9) The Aristotelian Virtue of Liberality could be interpreted to include passing on beneficial learnings.

(10) It is possible that the Existentialists (most notably Albert Camus) are ultimately wrong about meaning. Perhaps there could be a break though in science that definitively proves the existence of something we could call god or in some other way reveals what the meaning or purpose of humanity is. The discovery of the theory of everything perhaps, which by definition must include humanity. Perhaps there could be an agreement about meaning or purpose that, even though it may not be able to be proven 100%, may become nearly universally accepted as most likely right. It may be possible, but I will leave it up to others to assess the likelihood of either of these options.

(11) This is not an ethical duty. Ethics is about how we interact with and treat other people, not about how we treat ourselves. Regardless it still has importance.

(12) The Ubermensche concept is flawed in that while it advocates self mastery it does not advocate philosophical ethical responsibility to other people, except if the Ubermensche individually decides to give other people ethical weight. Nietzsche indicates it is acceptable to use others as a means to the Ubermensche's goals only restrained by whatever ethics the Ubermensche decides is appropriate - which could be none.

* * * * * * *

Oversite Home Page.





Top of Page
| Site Information | (C) |