Death Taxes and Gift Tax
Talk about poisonous words, death and taxes - no one wants either.
It is no wonder this is a difficult sell for politicians. However it
seems to me that this is a reasonable time to tax an estate.
Australia use to have death taxes. They were levied by the States.
But then one State - Queensland - had a brainwave thinking they
would attract retirees to the State - abolished their death taxes
(or death duties as they were called). Once this happened all the
other States were virtually obliged to abolish their death taxes or
risk an exodus of retirees. There was no benefit to Queensland -
only a loss of revenue to all States.
I would propose a tax of say 25% on the value of the estate over,
say, $2.5 million. And maybe a higher rate on estates over, say, $10
million. (These figures - to be determined.) The value of the estate
would include all houses, including primary residences (however the
primary residence would need to be treated differently to other
assets to prevent perverse outcomes from attempts at avoidance).
However the $2.5 million threshold means that the majority of
estates, even those with normal residential houses, will not be
impacted. There has to be an associated gift tax to limit avoidance.
Various details have to be worked out associated with dealing with
the estates where the deceased had a spouse and the assets split -
as I said these are just kernels of ideas.
The only deduction I would allow to this tax is if the estate has
left a bequest to registered charitable organisation(s) or to set up
a charitable organisation which would be approved by the charities
commission. To encourage charitable donation from the estate I would
make it charitable donation deductible at twice the rate (or some
other multiple) from the value of the estate for tax purposes. This
is justifiable as it encourages donation of money which goes to
community uses at many times the amount that would otherwise be
collected by the government from the death tax.
To illustrate this an example: An estate is valued at $5 million and
the will has made charitable bequests to registered charities
totaling $500,000. The amount of death tax payable would be
($5million - $2.5 million - 2 x $500,000) x 25% = $350,000. (Total
payment to charities and for tax - $850,000.) This still
leaves plenty of money for the beneficiaries. And the majority of
people would not have to pay death taxes at all as most estates
would be valued below $2.5 million.
Next Page - Wealth Tax
Reform Home Page
Oversite Home Page.